Sat. Dec 14th, 2024

Their mortgage was bogging them down, so they sold their apartment in Singapore and bought a smaller one. It was a blast from the past.<!-- wp:html --><p>The centerpiece of the apartment is the kitchen island and adjoining dining table.</p> <p class="copyright">Amanda Goh/Insider</p> <p>Tobby Toh and Goh Kai Yi downsized to a three-room public housing apartment in Singapore in 2021.<br /> The couple paid 300,000 Singapore dollars, or about $220,000 for the house.<br /> They turned the place into a vintage-inspired home, and say they no longer have any housing debt.</p> <p>When Tobby Toh and Goh Kai Yi were looking for a new home, they knew they wanted a smaller place.</p> <p>At that point, they were still living in their four-room <a href="https://www.businessinsider.com/singapore-architecture-shows-why-it-is-blue-zone-dan-buettner-2023-9">public housing apartment in Singapore</a>. It was a built-to-order, or BTO, flat that they bought in 2017, a year after they had gotten married.</p> <p>BTO flats are new apartments sold by the Housing Development Board on a <a href="https://www.hdb.gov.sg/about-us/news-and-publications/publications/hdbspeaks/an-hdb-flat-for-your-different-life-cycle-needs" target="_blank" rel="noopener">99-year lease</a>. In Singapore, there are strict rules around who's eligible to buy a BTO apartment. These rules vary depending on <a href="https://www.hdb.gov.sg/residential/buying-a-flat/understanding-your-eligibility-and-housing-loan-options/flat-and-grant-eligibility/singles">marital status</a> and other <a href="https://www.hdb.gov.sg/residential/buying-a-flat/understanding-your-eligibility-and-housing-loan-options/flat-and-grant-eligibility/couples-and-families" target="_blank" rel="noopener">family situations</a>, including non-Singaporean spouses and multigenerational households. </p> <p>The apartments are often <a href="https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/housing/bigger-bto-flats-in-serangoon-draw-more-than-13-first-timer-applicants-for-each-unit-on-offer" target="_blank" rel="noopener">oversubscribed</a>, so even the shortlisted applicants must go through a <a href="https://www.hdb.gov.sg/about-us/news-and-publications/publications/hdbspeaks/balloting-process-for-buildtoorder-bto-flats#ProvisionalTenderResults-1">balloting process</a> to determine if they're allocated a flat.</p> <p>Despite being lucky to score a home, Toh and Goh found it difficult to make their monthly payments. "We were always bogged down by our mortgage," Goh, a 35-year-old user experience designer, told Insider. </p> <p>Tobby Toh and Goh Kaiyi bought a three-room flat in Geylang Bahru.</p> <p class="copyright">Tobby Toh and Goh Kaiyi</p> <p>After doing some calculations, the couple realized they would no longer have to deal with housing debt if they sold their home and downgraded to a smaller apartment, she added.</p> <p>In December 2021, they took the plunge: They sold their BTO home for 628,000 Singapore dollars, or $460,000 — close to double what they had paid five years earlier — and bought a three-room apartment for SG$300,000.</p> <p>Based on the latest data from local real-estate platform <a href="https://stackedhomes.com/editorial/most-profitable-btos-in-2023-these-ulu-btos-in-the-north-made-almost-3x-for-its-owners/#gs.5nbztb" target="_blank" rel="noopener">StackedHomes</a>, others who recently sold their 4-room BTO flats in the same part of Singapore have made profits of over 70%.</p> <h2>By paying for their new house in cash, they no longer need to service a mortgage. </h2> <p>In Singapore, apartments developed by the Housing Development Board, or HDB, must be <a href="https://www.hdb.gov.sg/residential/selling-a-flat/eligibility">occupied for a minimum number of years</a> before they can be sold on the open market.</p> <p>When the minimum occupation period ends, some of those living in BTOs will take the chance to flip their homes, make a profit, and buy a bigger place, Toh, a 36-year-old who was working in finance, told Insider. </p> <p>The exterior of the couple's apartment block.</p> <p class="copyright">Amanda Goh/Insider</p> <p>"But having a bigger house, or a bigger car doesn't necessarily translate to a better quality of life for me," Toh said. "For us, we downsized to free up the obligations to pay every month. Then we can have the additional funds to go and do what we want."</p> <p>In fact, they are planning to take a long holiday overseas soon, he added.</p> <h2>The flat they bought also has sentimental value: It was Toh's childhood home.</h2> <p>A before photo of the couple's living room.</p> <p class="copyright">Tobby Toh and Goh Kaiyi</p> <p>When the couple decided to downsize, they already knew that they wanted to buy over Toh's childhood home.</p> <p>At the time, Toh's mother still owned the apartment but had moved out to live with his aunt a few blocks away. The flat had been rented out for the past nine years, he said. </p> <p>"It's like killing two birds with one stone: I thought if I bought the house back from my mom, she could use the money as well," Toh said.</p> <h2>Their apartment measures about 731 square feet and was built in 1978.</h2> <p>A before photo of the couple's kitchen and dining area.</p> <p class="copyright">Tobby Toh and Goh Kaiyi</p> <p>Due to its age, the 45-year-old apartment wasn't exactly in the most well-kept condition, Toh said. Some of the wall tiles were cracked, and the window grilles were falling off.</p> <p>Everything about the look and feel of the space was outdated, and walking into the home felt like stepping into the past, he added.</p> <p>To put the age of their home into perspective, the first HDB apartment blocks in Singapore were <a href="https://www.roots.gov.sg/en/places/places-landing/Places/landmarks/my-queenstown-heritage-trail/the-first-hdb-blocks-the-hdb-terraces#:~:text=Blocks%2045%2C%2048%20%26%2049%20Stirling,work%20on%20in%20the%201950s." target="_blank" rel="noopener">completed in 1960</a> — only 18 years earlier than their apartment block. In other older housing estates like theirs, the government even ends up buying back the properties <a href="https://www.hdb.gov.sg/residential/living-in-an-hdb-flat/sers-and-upgrading-programmes/sers">to demolish them and redevelop the area.</a></p> <p>A before photo of the couple's kitchen and living room, as viewed from the kitchen.</p> <p class="copyright">Tobby Toh and Goh Kaiyi</p> <p>Appearance aside, one thing the couple was sold on was the location: The apartment was located in Geylang Bahru, which is in the central region of Singapore. </p> <p>Their house is about a <a href="https://www.google.com/maps/dir/96+Geylang+Bahru,+Singapore+330096/Kallang+Bahru,+Geylang+Bahru+MRT+Station+(DT24),+Singapore/@1.3223196,103.8682701,17z/data=!3m2!4b1!5s0x31da190eb482b6bb:0xad0170a7fffe880b!4m14!4m13!1m5!1m1!1s0x31da182b0f745cf9:0xd342f419f36214dd!2m2!1d103.8703998!2d1.3234225!1m5!1m1!1s0x31da1990176581cb:0xd61dcfc6ce065d24!2m2!1d103.8716167!2d1.3214581!3e2?entry=ttu">five-minute walk</a> from the nearest subway station and a <a href="https://www.google.com/maps/dir/96+Geylang+Bahru,+Singapore+330096/Raffles+Place,+Raffles+Place+MRT+Station+(NS26%2FEW14),+Singapore/@1.3021407,103.8379755,14z/data=!3m2!4b1!5s0x31da190eb482b6bb:0xad0170a7fffe880b!4m14!4m13!1m5!1m1!1s0x31da182b0f745cf9:0xd342f419f36214dd!2m2!1d103.8703998!2d1.3234225!1m5!1m1!1s0x31da1975e523fdd7:0x8f5e81e2b4516e2f!2m2!1d103.8514941!2d1.2838742!3e0?entry=ttu">15-minute drive from the city center</a>.</p> <p>The open-concept kitchen and dining area features an exposed brick wall.</p> <p class="copyright">Amanda Goh/Insider</p> <h2>The couple finds it hard to describe their interior design aesthetic.</h2> <p>"We feel like our aesthetic is a little raw and slightly vintage," Goh said. That said, the couple admits that they didn't follow a specific aesthetic when trying to design their home.</p> <p>"We just wanted to keep things functional and basic. Even with the color palette we decided to go fairly neutral, with green, white, raw wood finishes, and exposed concrete," Toh added.</p> <p>The primary living area has a minimalist design.</p> <p class="copyright">Amanda Goh/Insider</p> <h2>The layout was planned based on what worked and what didn't in their previous home.</h2> <p>Their current home was slightly smaller than their previous house. To open up the layout, the couple knocked down a few walls and created new doorways.</p> <p>They wanted a kitchen island this time around, as Goh said she remembered them fighting over the stove when they had it lined up against a wall.</p> <p>Their new kitchen island doubles as a dining space to accommodate guests.</p> <p>The centerpiece of the apartment is the kitchen island and adjoining dining table.</p> <p class="copyright">Amanda Goh/Insider</p> <p>"We wanted a place where everyone could hang out. From our previous experience, we learned that people will gather wherever there's food," Toh said.</p> <p>Having an island between the kitchen and the living room helps bridge the two common spaces, he said.</p> <p>"This is like the centerpiece of the house where we can cook, host, and serve," he added.</p> <p>There is an exposed concrete beam above their sofa. The exposed concrete beam used to be part of a wall that separated the living room from what is now their home office.</p> <p class="copyright">Amanda Goh/Insider</p> <h2>Some prominent interior design features are the exposed concrete beam and feature wall.</h2> <p>The decision to have these exposed concrete features was inspired by some design references they had found.</p> <p>"We originally intended to just have one wall, but as they were hacking, we saw corners of plaster on the overhead beam peeling, and we thought we should just expose it as well," Goh said. Thankfully, it came out the way they wanted.</p> <p>The couple tried to do something similar in their previous house, but it didn't look natural that time around.</p> <p>"It's only in old HDBs where you can do this because in the new HDBs when you try to hack the walls, the materials are different," Goh said. "You won't get this kind of effect."</p> <p>The couple has a chalkboard wall in the house.</p> <p class="copyright">Amanda Goh/Insider</p> <h2>The couple designed the place on their own and worked directly with the contractors.</h2> <p>"We did approach designers, but we didn't go ahead with it because we just felt that we already knew what we wanted," Goh said. </p> <p>The couple ended up managing the entire renovation project on their own while juggling full-time jobs. It taught them the importance of being specific when it comes to design directions.</p> <p>"It's just that I think these contractors, they wouldn't have aesthetic inputs," Goh said. "Basically when it comes to alignment or certain materials, you have to be very specific on what you want."</p> <p>The couple's office area.</p> <p class="copyright">Amanda Goh/Insider</p> <p>The couple remodeled almost the entire home — the only things they kept were the old tiles that they incorporated into the floors in the coffee-making corner.</p> <p>Their renovations took about three months, but they moved in before the house was complete. There were still some minor installations left, Goh said.</p> <p>Since the couple downsized their home, they also had to declutter. Apart from getting rid of items they no longer wanted, they also sold off their appliances to buy smaller ones that would fit more comfortably into their home.</p> <p>The couple turned the back of their home into a balcony-like space with a coffee-making corner and window-side counter. The space doubles as a service yard.</p> <p class="copyright">Amanda Goh/Insider</p> <h2>The couple also did some DIY projects around the apartment.</h2> <p>They wanted a microcement finish in their bathroom, which was supposed to be completed by an external contractor.</p> <p>However the cost that they were quoted ended up going beyond their budget, so the couple decided to take things into their own hands.</p> <p>"When we did the bathroom, it's like, there's no way you can just do it halfway and leave it," Toh said. "Because once you start you'll have to do three layers. And for every layer in between, you have to wait."</p> <p>A composite image of the couple's two bathrooms. One is a toilet and the other is a shower.</p> <p class="copyright">Amanda Goh/Insider</p> <p>Things were further complicated by their decision to turn the common bathroom into a half bath and the master bathroom into a shower-only washroom.</p> <p>"Basically we couldn't use the shower for about a month," Goh said. They ended up installing a temporary shower head in the common bathroom during that period.</p> <p>The master bedroom.</p> <p class="copyright">Amanda Goh/Insider</p> <h2>The couple has a piece of advice for anyone who wants to design their own homes: Don't blindly follow trends.</h2> <p>It's more important to design something that fits with your own tastes and preferences, Toh said. </p> <p>After all, a home should be a reflection of the owner's personality and not a reflection of the latest trends because "trends will just die," Goh said.</p> <p>"To me, functionality is also important," she added. "I mean you have to design a space around your own habits. If you are a messy person and you try to go with a minimalist theme, it's just not going to work."</p> <p><em>The couple provided Insider with proof of their house sale and purchase. </em></p> <div class="read-original">Read the original article on <a href="https://www.businessinsider.com/millennial-couple-singapore-downsized-home-hdb-mortgage-debt-free-2023-9">Business Insider</a></div><!-- /wp:html -->

The centerpiece of the apartment is the kitchen island and adjoining dining table.

Tobby Toh and Goh Kai Yi downsized to a three-room public housing apartment in Singapore in 2021.
The couple paid 300,000 Singapore dollars, or about $220,000 for the house.
They turned the place into a vintage-inspired home, and say they no longer have any housing debt.

When Tobby Toh and Goh Kai Yi were looking for a new home, they knew they wanted a smaller place.

At that point, they were still living in their four-room public housing apartment in Singapore. It was a built-to-order, or BTO, flat that they bought in 2017, a year after they had gotten married.

BTO flats are new apartments sold by the Housing Development Board on a 99-year lease. In Singapore, there are strict rules around who’s eligible to buy a BTO apartment. These rules vary depending on marital status and other family situations, including non-Singaporean spouses and multigenerational households. 

The apartments are often oversubscribed, so even the shortlisted applicants must go through a balloting process to determine if they’re allocated a flat.

Despite being lucky to score a home, Toh and Goh found it difficult to make their monthly payments. “We were always bogged down by our mortgage,” Goh, a 35-year-old user experience designer, told Insider. 

Tobby Toh and Goh Kaiyi bought a three-room flat in Geylang Bahru.

After doing some calculations, the couple realized they would no longer have to deal with housing debt if they sold their home and downgraded to a smaller apartment, she added.

In December 2021, they took the plunge: They sold their BTO home for 628,000 Singapore dollars, or $460,000 — close to double what they had paid five years earlier — and bought a three-room apartment for SG$300,000.

Based on the latest data from local real-estate platform StackedHomes, others who recently sold their 4-room BTO flats in the same part of Singapore have made profits of over 70%.

By paying for their new house in cash, they no longer need to service a mortgage. 

In Singapore, apartments developed by the Housing Development Board, or HDB, must be occupied for a minimum number of years before they can be sold on the open market.

When the minimum occupation period ends, some of those living in BTOs will take the chance to flip their homes, make a profit, and buy a bigger place, Toh, a 36-year-old who was working in finance, told Insider. 

The exterior of the couple’s apartment block.

“But having a bigger house, or a bigger car doesn’t necessarily translate to a better quality of life for me,” Toh said. “For us, we downsized to free up the obligations to pay every month. Then we can have the additional funds to go and do what we want.”

In fact, they are planning to take a long holiday overseas soon, he added.

The flat they bought also has sentimental value: It was Toh’s childhood home.

A before photo of the couple’s living room.

When the couple decided to downsize, they already knew that they wanted to buy over Toh’s childhood home.

At the time, Toh’s mother still owned the apartment but had moved out to live with his aunt a few blocks away. The flat had been rented out for the past nine years, he said. 

“It’s like killing two birds with one stone: I thought if I bought the house back from my mom, she could use the money as well,” Toh said.

Their apartment measures about 731 square feet and was built in 1978.

A before photo of the couple’s kitchen and dining area.

Due to its age, the 45-year-old apartment wasn’t exactly in the most well-kept condition, Toh said. Some of the wall tiles were cracked, and the window grilles were falling off.

Everything about the look and feel of the space was outdated, and walking into the home felt like stepping into the past, he added.

To put the age of their home into perspective, the first HDB apartment blocks in Singapore were completed in 1960 — only 18 years earlier than their apartment block. In other older housing estates like theirs, the government even ends up buying back the properties to demolish them and redevelop the area.

A before photo of the couple’s kitchen and living room, as viewed from the kitchen.

Appearance aside, one thing the couple was sold on was the location: The apartment was located in Geylang Bahru, which is in the central region of Singapore. 

Their house is about a five-minute walk from the nearest subway station and a 15-minute drive from the city center.

The open-concept kitchen and dining area features an exposed brick wall.

The couple finds it hard to describe their interior design aesthetic.

“We feel like our aesthetic is a little raw and slightly vintage,” Goh said. That said, the couple admits that they didn’t follow a specific aesthetic when trying to design their home.

“We just wanted to keep things functional and basic. Even with the color palette we decided to go fairly neutral, with green, white, raw wood finishes, and exposed concrete,” Toh added.

The primary living area has a minimalist design.

The layout was planned based on what worked and what didn’t in their previous home.

Their current home was slightly smaller than their previous house. To open up the layout, the couple knocked down a few walls and created new doorways.

They wanted a kitchen island this time around, as Goh said she remembered them fighting over the stove when they had it lined up against a wall.

Their new kitchen island doubles as a dining space to accommodate guests.

The centerpiece of the apartment is the kitchen island and adjoining dining table.

“We wanted a place where everyone could hang out. From our previous experience, we learned that people will gather wherever there’s food,” Toh said.

Having an island between the kitchen and the living room helps bridge the two common spaces, he said.

“This is like the centerpiece of the house where we can cook, host, and serve,” he added.

There is an exposed concrete beam above their sofa. The exposed concrete beam used to be part of a wall that separated the living room from what is now their home office.

Some prominent interior design features are the exposed concrete beam and feature wall.

The decision to have these exposed concrete features was inspired by some design references they had found.

“We originally intended to just have one wall, but as they were hacking, we saw corners of plaster on the overhead beam peeling, and we thought we should just expose it as well,” Goh said. Thankfully, it came out the way they wanted.

The couple tried to do something similar in their previous house, but it didn’t look natural that time around.

“It’s only in old HDBs where you can do this because in the new HDBs when you try to hack the walls, the materials are different,” Goh said. “You won’t get this kind of effect.”

The couple has a chalkboard wall in the house.

The couple designed the place on their own and worked directly with the contractors.

“We did approach designers, but we didn’t go ahead with it because we just felt that we already knew what we wanted,” Goh said. 

The couple ended up managing the entire renovation project on their own while juggling full-time jobs. It taught them the importance of being specific when it comes to design directions.

“It’s just that I think these contractors, they wouldn’t have aesthetic inputs,” Goh said. “Basically when it comes to alignment or certain materials, you have to be very specific on what you want.”

The couple’s office area.

The couple remodeled almost the entire home — the only things they kept were the old tiles that they incorporated into the floors in the coffee-making corner.

Their renovations took about three months, but they moved in before the house was complete. There were still some minor installations left, Goh said.

Since the couple downsized their home, they also had to declutter. Apart from getting rid of items they no longer wanted, they also sold off their appliances to buy smaller ones that would fit more comfortably into their home.

The couple turned the back of their home into a balcony-like space with a coffee-making corner and window-side counter. The space doubles as a service yard.

The couple also did some DIY projects around the apartment.

They wanted a microcement finish in their bathroom, which was supposed to be completed by an external contractor.

However the cost that they were quoted ended up going beyond their budget, so the couple decided to take things into their own hands.

“When we did the bathroom, it’s like, there’s no way you can just do it halfway and leave it,” Toh said. “Because once you start you’ll have to do three layers. And for every layer in between, you have to wait.”

A composite image of the couple’s two bathrooms. One is a toilet and the other is a shower.

Things were further complicated by their decision to turn the common bathroom into a half bath and the master bathroom into a shower-only washroom.

“Basically we couldn’t use the shower for about a month,” Goh said. They ended up installing a temporary shower head in the common bathroom during that period.

The master bedroom.

The couple has a piece of advice for anyone who wants to design their own homes: Don’t blindly follow trends.

It’s more important to design something that fits with your own tastes and preferences, Toh said. 

After all, a home should be a reflection of the owner’s personality and not a reflection of the latest trends because “trends will just die,” Goh said.

“To me, functionality is also important,” she added. “I mean you have to design a space around your own habits. If you are a messy person and you try to go with a minimalist theme, it’s just not going to work.”

The couple provided Insider with proof of their house sale and purchase. 

Read the original article on Business Insider

By