Russian President Vladimir Putin.
Contributor via Getty Images
An ex-CIA analyst says Russia might risk nuclear war with NATO to prevail in their war with Ukraine.Peter Schroeder says Putin has been “remarkably consistent” about using nuclear weapons on NATO.Putin said recently that Russia had no interest in fighting NATO forces.
An ex-CIA analyst says the US might be underestimating the possibility of nuclear war between Russia and NATO.
“That is a mistake. US officials have it backward,” Peter Schroeder wrote in an article for Foreign Affairs published on Wednesday.
“It is actually quite unlikely that Russian President Vladimir Putin will use a nuclear weapon on the battlefield in Ukraine, but it is very possible that he will move toward using one against NATO,” Schroeder added.
The former public servant spent nearly two decades working on issues relating to Russia. Besides working for the CIA, Schroeder had done stints at the US embassy in Moscow and the National Intelligence Council.
“When Putin invokes his arsenal, he is not trying to warn that Russia could use tactical nuclear weapons in Ukraine. Rather, his rhetoric is designed to threaten NATO itself,” Schroeder said in his article.
Schroeder said that Putin wasn’t just engaging in saber-rattling whenever he touted Russia’s nuclear capabilities. He believes that going nuclear is something Putin could actually do if he wanted to win the war in Ukraine swiftly.
“Unlike the West, Putin may not fear a nuclear standoff: he is well-versed in Russia’s nuclear arsenal and the tenets of nuclear deterrence, and possibly sees himself as uniquely suited to navigating a nuclear crisis,” Schroeder wrote.
“And Putin has been remarkably consistent that Russia is willing to use nuclear weapons against NATO to defend its interests in Ukraine,” he added, referencing Putin’s remarks eight years ago when he said Russia was ready to mobilize its nuclear forces during its invasion of Crimea.
Schroeder then outlined how Putin could ratchet up Russia’s pressure against NATO.
“If Putin does escalate the war, for instance by attacking NATO with conventional weapons, he will likely move very swiftly, so as not to give the United States a chance to maneuver away from a crisis,” he wrote.
“From there, Moscow might actually begin using force against NATO,” Schroeder said, adding that Russia could attack NATO aircraft, ships, and convoys to drag NATO into the fight.
“Finally, in a worst-case scenario—one where the Kremlin sought to shock the world into ending the war in Ukraine quickly and on Putin’s terms—Russia could actually launch a nuclear weapon directly at NATO territory,” Schroeder continued.
Both the US and Russia have sought to downplay the possibility of nuclear war.
In July, US President Joe Biden said at a press conference in Helsinki that there wasn’t any danger of Russia using nuclear weapons on Ukraine.
“I don’t think there’s any real prospect, you never know, of Putin using nuclear weapons,” Biden said then.
Last week, Russian leader Vladimir Putin brushed aside Biden’s comments on how Russia would attack NATO after defeating Ukraine.
“Russia has no reason, no interest, no geopolitical interest, neither economic, political nor military, to fight with NATO countries,” Putin said in a televised interview on Sunday.
Representatives for Schroeder, the White House, and the Russian foreign and defense ministries did not immediately respond to requests for comment from Business Insider sent outside regular business hours.